Precamp Videos 2013 - Set 2

Set 2 Clip 1

link for tablets: youtu.be

You have no rights to post comments

Comments   

 
Paulo Mina
#1 Paulo Mina 2013-08-18 15:32
Defensive foul. Obstruction from number 15.
 
 
V'yacheslav Slyusar
#2 V'yacheslav Slyusar 2013-08-18 18:59
Offensive foul. One foot or both feet may be off the floor for defensive player if he moving laterally, but not towards the player with the ball.
 
 
Paulo Rocha Martins
#3 Paulo Rocha Martins 2013-08-18 20:39
Offensive foul. The defender moves laterally but still he remains with a legal guading position as the principles of time and distance do not aplly.
 
 
Michał Proc
#4 Michał Proc 2013-08-18 20:46
No call looks good for me it's light contact. Lead referee have a bad angle in this situation, he shouldn't be under the basket.
 
 
Tomasz Tybor
#5 Tomasz Tybor 2013-08-18 21:22
The defender moves laterally, but not towards the player with the ball.Offensive foul.
 
 
Michał Sosin
#6 Michał Sosin 2013-08-18 21:41
In my opinion defensive player set up legal guarding position. She is moving laterally to defend. That's why we can't punish the defender. The contact is not so strong. In my opinion no call.
 
 
Ranno Konks
#7 Ranno Konks 2013-08-19 07:37
In my opinion defensive foul, because defensive player late and did not reach the legal defense posistion.
 
 
Michel Patrick Glod
#8 Michel Patrick Glod 2013-08-19 08:33
Very intersting situation.
The defender did a good job, legal guarding position established.
On the drive to the basket a contact occured, and the referees, who had a good position did not call anything. We can see that one referee (Trail) did (unofficial FIBA signal) in pointing the direction (let's go). The referee Team decided to let it go and gave a "No-call", what for me in this situation was a good decision. The offensive team, reached their goal, and made a basket, so nobody will complain if you "let the music play".
When we think about charge/block, no-call and or flopping by defender, we should leave the last options by side, if the defender did a good job, he can't be punished. so we have one option --> charge?
But we should think about: advantage / disadvantage, a player on the floor can not play basketball neither defence nor offense. so he was placed in disadvantage after the contact.
Charge ?
To conclude, in this situation "best call - No-call
 
 
Pierre-Yves De Soete
#9 Pierre-Yves De Soete 2013-08-19 08:54
For me No-call is a good option. The defender has a good legal position, and maintains it. Even if he is out of the non-charge semi circle, it's a light contact. I believe that for the game, this contact should not be called.
 
 
Ewa Matuszewska
#10 Ewa Matuszewska 2013-08-19 09:13
The defender had legal guarding position but contact was not very strong. For me is a no call situation.
 
 
Jakub Pietrzak
#11 Jakub Pietrzak 2013-08-19 10:00
No call in my opinion, legal defender, small contact
 
 
Robert Rydz
#12 Robert Rydz 2013-08-19 11:34
No call in my opinion
 
 
Sayaka Kai
#13 Sayaka Kai 2013-08-19 11:40
Offensive foul.Because defensive player set up legal guarding position,offens ive player should stop. Defensive player's action is not flopping.
 
 
Anja Rubach
#14 Anja Rubach 2013-08-19 14:11
Defense player does not do anything wrong (legal defense position, movement sidewards or backwards and contact on the torso) but not a hard contact - no call (as decided here) is a good solution!
 
 
Tomasz Szczurewski
#15 Tomasz Szczurewski 2013-08-19 17:04
For me it's a no call. Good D - play by defender and too small contact to call a charge. In my opinion Lead's position is not so good in this situation, because he was directly under the blackboard and from that place he saw only back of defensive player.
 
 
Bartosz Puzoń
#16 Bartosz Puzoń 2013-08-19 17:11
Legal defender. Small contact. no call.
L shouldn't go under the basket
 
 
Maciej Dębowski
#17 Maciej Dębowski 2013-08-19 17:58
4 me - no call, as it was called in the game. L ref should not be so penetrated under the basket.
 
 
Bartosz Koralewski
#18 Bartosz Koralewski 2013-08-19 20:16
for me is no call, defender going sidewards. There is a small contact.
 
 
Ievgenii Nagornyi
#19 Ievgenii Nagornyi 2013-08-19 21:26
No foul for me.
 
 
Tom Muller
#20 Tom Muller 2013-08-19 23:15
The defensive player has a legal defensive position when contact happens, the offensive player doesn't do any excessive move as charging the defense. Contact is light, maybe flopping. Looks like no call to me.
The lead referee cannot see what happens, he doesn't see the space between the players, from there he can only guess and would need the help of the trail (2 men here) who is far away.
 
 
Arkadiusz Wojna
#21 Arkadiusz Wojna 2013-08-20 09:40
In my opinion - no call, that was a incidental contact
 
 
Tomasz Langowski
#22 Tomasz Langowski 2013-08-20 11:23
The defender moves laterally in a legal defensive position. The offensive player makes a normal, natural move to the basket and contact isn't strong. No call in my opinion.
 
 
Paweł Berdyczko
#23 Paweł Berdyczko 2013-08-20 12:09
I also think that it should be NO CALL decision but I'm not quite sure if the contact is in torso of defensive player. Defender established LGP and moved according the rules. Contact was caused by offensive player and looks like soft one. Also reaction of the defender looks like he would fall down. The Lead referee should not be under the basket to make good decision but stay outside the paint.
 
 
Chris Chapman
#24 Chris Chapman 2013-08-20 17:55
No call. Legal guarding position established by defender and soft contact from offensive player who is also going slightly away from the basket. Lead would have had a better position if he had stayed to the left of the key (starting lead position)
 
 
Manuel Maia
#25 Manuel Maia 2013-08-20 22:44
For me, the best decision is no call. The defensive player is in a legal position and the contact is legal and not relevant.
 
 
Adam Wierzman
#26 Adam Wierzman 2013-08-21 08:08
My decision:
No call.
Comments:
LGP established, slight contact.
 
 
Lorenzo Ferroni
#27 Lorenzo Ferroni 2013-08-21 11:55
No call.
There is a light movment in extension from the offense, but it's not enough for call a foul. Defensive position is not the best, ma he has not advantage from the situation.
So no call.
 
 
Jacek Dolski
#28 Jacek Dolski 2013-08-22 16:30
It's no call situation. Lead position is not very good. He schould stand more on the right side of basket.
 
 
Jakub Zamojski
#29 Jakub Zamojski 2013-08-23 20:42
The most important in this situation is that L referee put himself into possition that he can only guess how strong contact was, or may be flop or...(what nobody mention) when ofensive player jump from the court - and as we all know this is very important , as we change the rule to "defence player in the air". But look how easy it is when you have good possition.
 
 
Michał Pietrakiewicz
#30 Michał Pietrakiewicz 2013-08-23 22:03
Legal defensive position, contact wasn't big - for me no call.
 
 
Tiberiu Lucaciu
#31 Tiberiu Lucaciu 2013-08-24 16:11
No call
 
 
Michał Gąsiński
#32 Michał Gąsiński 2013-08-24 18:52
For me it is no call, Defensive palyer has legal position and contact is not strong.
 
 
Rene Brandstoetter
#33 Rene Brandstoetter 2013-08-25 13:52
No call, def. Player good position, off. Player not hard contact
 
 
Joe Jungels
#34 Joe Jungels 2013-08-26 11:45
No call is a good decision for this scene. L referee also had a good position to take his decision.
 

CONTACT US

Jakub Zamojski

Mobile: +48601736920
Email: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

 

Editor
Marta Seweryn

Mobile: +36304984354
Email:  This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
 

Technical and Website Support 
Pawel Berdyczko

Mobile: +48883321499
Email: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Antalya 2015